Abandon the inspection?

Walk away now and your findings go in the bin. The bible gets to call that a pass.

← The Evidence Room

Exhibit No. 25

True

No. 25

jesus describes the end of the world: the sun goes dark, the stars fall, and he comes back on the clouds while angels gather his followers. Then he tells his listeners that all of it will happen before their generation dies. Earlier he told them some of the people standing there would live to see it.

Matthew 24:34 (with 16:28)

Original wording

Matthew 24:34: Verily I say unto you, This generation shall not pass, till all these things be fulfilled. Matthew 16:28: Verily I say unto you, There be some standing here, which shall not taste of death, till they see the Son of man coming in his kingdom.

Matthew 24:34 (with 16:28), King James Version.

Who’s who
jesus
A Jewish preacher from Galilee, in what is now northern Israel, executed by the Romans around 30 CE. christians believe he was god in human form and that he will return.
Son of man
A title jesus uses for himself, borrowed from the Old Testament book of Daniel, where a heavenly figure “like the Son of man” comes with the clouds and is given an everlasting kingdom.
the temple
The great temple in Jerusalem, the centre of Jewish worship. Matthew 24 opens with jesus predicting it will be torn down. The Romans destroyed it in 70 CE.
Matthew
One of the four gospels, the books that tell jesus’s life. Probably written several decades after his death.
What christians say

There are three main readings. Some christians, called preterists, say it did happen: “these things” means the destruction of Jerusalem and the temple in 70 CE, about forty years later, well within a generation, and the sun, moon and stars are the same poetic language the Old Testament prophets used for the fall of a nation, as when Isaiah describes the fall of Babylon. Others say “this generation” means the generation that sees the signs begin, whenever that is. Others say the Greek word, genea, can mean a race or people, so jesus was promising that the Jewish people would survive until the end. As for Matthew 16:28, the very next chapter has three disciples see jesus transfigured in glory on a mountain six days later, which many take to be what he meant.

Where that breaks

The preterist reading deserves credit, because part of it works. The temple really was destroyed within forty years, just as jesus says at the start of the chapter, and the prophets really did use falling stars as poetry for the fall of a kingdom. But the chapter doesn’t stop at the temple. Verse 30 has all the tribes of the earth seeing the Son of man coming on the clouds, verse 31 has angels gathering the chosen from one end of heaven to the other, and Matthew 16:27, the verse right before the second promise, has him coming to “reward every man according to his works.” That’s the final judgement, and even preterists mostly agree it hasn’t happened yet. The other two readings each redefine a word. Matthew uses “this generation” over and over to mean the people jesus is talking to, including a chapter earlier, “All these things shall come upon this generation,” and earlier in chapter 16 itself, where he calls the crowd a “wicked and adulterous generation.” Nobody reads those as “the Jewish race” or “some future group.” The early christians read it the plain way too: Paul, writing in the 50s CE, expected that “we which are alive and remain” would be caught up to meet jesus in the air. C.S. Lewis, one of the most popular christian writers of the last century, called this “the most embarrassing verse in the Bible.” He was right, and it’s to his credit that he said so.

If it was all meant to happen before that generation died, how many generations have we been waiting now?