True
jesus says the kingdom of god is like a mustard seed. It’s the smallest seed on earth, he says, but it grows into the biggest plant in the garden, big enough for birds to shelter in.
Original wording
And he said, Whereunto shall we liken the kingdom of God? or with what comparison shall we compare it? It is like a grain of mustard seed, which, when it is sown in the earth, is less than all the seeds that be in the earth: But when it is sown, it groweth up, and becometh greater than all herbs, and shooteth out great branches; so that the fowls of the air may lodge under the shadow of it.
Who’s who
- jesus
- A Jewish preacher from Galilee, in what is now northern Israel, executed by the Romans around 30 CE. christians believe he was god in human form.
- kingdom of god
- What jesus called the new world god was going to bring about. Many of his parables are about it.
- parable
- A short story with a lesson, like a fable without the talking animals. jesus taught mostly in parables.
- mustard seed
- The seed of the mustard plant, about one to two millimetres across. The plant grows as a large bush.
- Mark
- The shortest of the four gospels, the books that tell jesus’s life. Most scholars think it was the first one written.
What christians say
This is a parable, not a botany lesson. jesus was speaking to farmers in Galilee, and the mustard seed was the smallest seed they sowed; later Jewish writings use “as small as a mustard seed” as a stock phrase for something tiny. The Greek word translated “earth” can also mean the ground or soil, so the verse can be read as “smaller than all the seeds sown in the ground,” meaning a field. The point of the parable, a small start with a huge result, stands whatever the size of an orchid seed.
Where that breaks
The point of the parable does stand. Small things grow into big things; nobody is disputing that. But the question here isn’t whether the lesson is nice, it’s whether the sentence is true, and the sentence says the mustard seed is smaller than all the seeds on the earth, and it isn’t. Orchid seeds are so small they drift like dust, and orchids grow wild in Galilee. Tobacco and begonia seeds are smaller too. ‘The smallest seed a farmer sowed’ is a reasonable thing for a first-century preacher to say. It is a strange thing for the creator of every seed to say, and christians say the speaker is both. Matthew’s version of the same parable goes further, calling it “the least of all seeds” and saying it becomes a tree. If the answer is that jesus was using the everyday knowledge of his audience, that’s fine, but then the book is only as accurate as its audience was, and the audience wasn’t the one claiming to be without error.
If jesus made every seed on earth, why did he think the mustard seed was the smallest one?