Abandon the inspection?

Walk away now and your findings go in the bin. The bible gets to call that a pass.

← The Evidence Room

Exhibit No. 26

Backed by evidence

No. 26

When jesus dies, the temple curtain rips from top to bottom, there’s an earthquake, and graves split open. Many dead holy people come back to life, walk into Jerusalem, and are seen by lots of people.

Matthew 27:51-53

Original wording

And, behold, the veil of the temple was rent in twain from the top to the bottom; and the earth did quake, and the rocks rent; And the graves were opened; and many bodies of the saints which slept arose, And came out of the graves after his resurrection, and went into the holy city, and appeared unto many.

Matthew 27:51-53, King James Version.

Who’s who
the temple
The main Jewish place of worship, in Jerusalem, destroyed by the Romans in 70 CE.
the veil of the temple
A huge curtain inside the temple that screened off its holiest room.
saints
Here it means faithful Jews who had died, not saints in the later Catholic sense.
the holy city
Jerusalem, where jesus was executed during Passover, the busiest festival of the Jewish year.
the gospels
The four books that tell jesus’s life, called Matthew, Mark, Luke and John. Only Matthew has this scene.
Paul
An early christian missionary whose letters, written in the 50s CE, are the oldest christian writings we have.
Josephus
A Jewish historian of the late first century who wrote long histories of the Jews, including Jerusalem under Pontius Pilate, the Roman governor who had jesus executed.
Philo
A Jewish philosopher in Alexandria, Egypt, who was alive when jesus died and wrote about Pilate.
Ezekiel
A Jewish prophet of the 500s BCE whose book has a famous vision of dead bones coming back to life.
Mike Licona
An evangelical christian historian who wrote a long scholarly defence of jesus’s resurrection.
What christians say

Many scholars, including some evangelicals, read these verses as apocalyptic imagery rather than a news report. Jewish writing used earthquakes and opened graves as signs that god was acting, as when Ezekiel has god say ‘I will open your graves’. Matthew is telling readers what jesus’s death means: the old order ending and the dead being promised new life. Mike Licona suggested reading it this way in The Resurrection of Jesus (2010). Others take it literally and point out that silence from other writers doesn’t prove it didn’t happen, since ancient historians left out plenty. A 2012 study of Dead Sea sediments even found signs of an earthquake in the region sometime around 26 to 36 CE.

Where that breaks

Concede the earthquake. The Jordan valley sits on a major fault line, earthquakes happen there, and one may well have struck around then. The dead people are the problem. This is a crowd of corpses walking into a city packed for Passover and appearing ‘unto many’, and nobody else noticed. Mark and Luke, telling the same death scene, have the torn curtain and nothing else: no earthquake, no open graves, no walking dead. John has none of it. Paul, writing decades before Matthew, lists everyone the risen jesus appeared to and never mentions another risen person. Josephus, who wrote about Jerusalem under Pilate, and Philo, who was alive at the time, say nothing. Matthew himself drops them: they come out, they appear, and they are never mentioned again, and nobody asks what they said or where they went next. As the King James punctuates it, they even rise on Friday and wait in their open graves until Sunday before coming out. The imagery answer is the honest one, and it concedes the round: it didn’t happen. It also leaves the reader of an execution report with no way to tell which dead people rising are symbols and which one is the whole religion.

If dead people climbed out of their graves and toured the city, why did nobody else think it worth writing down?