Backed by evidence
The bible says two million people walked out of Egypt in one night, then lived in a desert for forty years.
Original wording
And the children of Israel journeyed from Rameses to Succoth, about six hundred thousand on foot that were men, beside children.
Who’s who
- the Exodus
- The bible's story of the Israelites escaping slavery in Egypt, led by Moses. The founding event of the whole religion.
- Sinai
- The desert between Egypt and Israel. About the size of Ireland.
- Kadesh-Barnea
- An oasis the bible names as their main camp for most of the forty years. It's been excavated.
What christians say
Nomads leave little behind, and the Sinai hasn't been fully excavated. 'Thousand' in Hebrew may mean a military unit, which would make the group a few thousand people, not two million. A smaller exodus is plausible.
Where that breaks
Let's do the walk. Egypt had about three million people at the time, so the book has two out of every three of them leaving in one night, which must have been a quiet morning at the pyramids. Line them up ten wide and the queue is 150 miles long. The front reaches the sea while the back is still looking for its sandals. Then forty years in a desert with a few springs, drinking five million litres a day, burying about a million of their own, and somehow leaving behind zero graves, zero campfires, zero broken pots. The tidiest two million people in history. Archaeologists have found campsites from single families ten thousand years older than this. They've dug the exact spot the book says these people lived for most of those forty years. Nothing. Apparently they packed out. The best comeback from christian scholars is that 'thousand' might have meant a small squad, which would shrink the crowd to a few thousand. Great. That's a defence of the story that opens by admitting the story is off by a factor of several hundred, which is a strange way to defend something.
That's the entire population of Houston. Camping. In a desert. For forty years. And in all that time nobody dropped a cup, lost a sandal, or died anywhere we could find them. Remarkable discipline. Did it happen?