Moral guide
Women should learn quietly and do as they’re told. A woman may not teach a man or have any authority over him; she has to stay silent. The reason given: Adam was made first, and Eve was the one who got fooled.
Original wording
Let the woman learn in silence with all subjection. But I suffer not a woman to teach, nor to usurp authority over the man, but to be in silence. For Adam was first formed, then Eve. And Adam was not deceived, but the woman being deceived was in the transgression.
Who’s who
- Paul
- An early christian leader who wrote many of the letters in the New Testament. This letter carries his name, though most scholars think a later follower wrote it.
- Timothy
- A younger church leader the letter is addressed to, running the church in the city of Ephesus, in what is now Turkey.
- Adam and Eve
- The first man and woman in the bible’s creation story. Eve eats the forbidden fruit after a talking snake persuades her.
What christians say
This was written to one church with a specific problem: false teachers, and women who hadn’t yet had the chance to be educated. It isn’t a rule for all time. Many churches ordain women today. And even churches that keep the rule say it’s about roles in church leadership, not about worth; men and women are equal before god.
Where that breaks
The first part is a fair reading, and plenty of christians hold it. The trouble is the verses that follow. The letter doesn’t say “because the women in Ephesus aren’t educated yet.” It says because Adam was made first and Eve was deceived. That’s an argument from creation, which applies to every woman who has ever lived, and it’s the argument churches still use: the largest protestant denomination in America limits the office of pastor to men, citing scripture. “Equal in worth, but she can’t be in charge” is what every system of rank has said about the people at the bottom of it. And the next verse says she’ll be saved through having children.
So when your mum tells you to tidy your room, which one of you is breaking god’s law?