Kill the babies. Keep the virgins.
Orders god gives in person. The people who obey are the heroes.
Kill everything, including the babies still nursing.
Kill everything, including the babies still nursing.
God tells a king to attack a neighbouring tribe and kill everything: men, women, infants, babies still nursing, and the animals.
Why this is nonsense
The order comes from god, in words, and it names the babies. The king who spares a few animals is the one who gets punished.
Original wording
Now go and smite Amalek, and utterly destroy all that they have, and spare them not; but slay both man and woman, infant and suckling, ox and sheep, camel and ass.
Who’s who
- Saul
- The first king of Israel. Chosen by god, later rejected by god for not finishing this job.
- Amalek
- A tribe living south of Israel. Enemies going back generations.
What christians say
The Amalekites were uniquely wicked and had attacked Israel first. God, as the author of life, has the right to end it. And 'kill everything' is ancient war rhetoric, exaggeration that no one took literally.
Kill the babies too, god says. Is that good?
Kill the boys and the mothers. Keep the girls who are virgins.
Kill the boys and the mothers. Keep the girls who are virgins.
Moses, the most important prophet in the bible, orders his army to kill every boy and every woman who has slept with a man, and to keep the virgin girls for themselves.
Why this is nonsense
Kill the boys. Kill every woman who has slept with a man. The girls who haven't are kept for the soldiers. That's the order.
Original wording
Now therefore kill every male among the little ones, and kill every woman that hath known man by lying with him. But all the women children, that have not known a man by lying with him, keep alive for yourselves.
Who’s who
- Moses
- The man who led the Israelites out of Egypt and received the Ten Commandments. The bible's most important prophet.
- the Midianites
- A neighbouring tribe. This is the aftermath of Israel's attack on them.
What christians say
'Keep alive for yourselves' means as servants, not wives. The Midianites had lured Israel into idolatry, so this was judgement, not conquest. And it's the Old Testament, which christians are no longer under.
Kill the boys, kill the women, keep the virgin girls. Is that fit for a child?
The walls fall. Kill everyone inside, young and old.
The walls fall. Kill everyone inside, young and old.
The priests blow their horns, the army shouts, and the city wall falls flat. The Israelites walk straight in and kill everyone inside, men and women, young and old, and the animals too.
Why this is nonsense
The book lists men, women, young, old and the animals so you can't miss anyone. It's told as a victory.
Original wording
So the people shouted when the priests blew with the trumpets: and it came to pass, when the people heard the sound of the trumpet, and the people shouted with a great shout, that the wall fell down flat, so that the people went up into the city, every man straight before him, and they took the city. And they utterly destroyed all that was in the city, both man and woman, young and old, and ox, and sheep, and ass, with the edge of the sword.
Who’s who
- Jericho
- A city near the Jordan river, in what is now the West Bank. One of the oldest towns on earth, and one of the most thoroughly dug up.
- Joshua
- Moses’s successor, the general who leads the Israelites into Canaan after their forty years in the desert.
- the Israelites
- The people the book is about, arriving to take the land the book says god promised them.
- Canaan
- The land covering roughly modern Israel, the Palestinian territories and Lebanon.
- the priests
- Israel’s religious officials. For a week they march round the city carrying a sacred chest, the ark, and blowing rams’ horns.
- John Garstang
- A British archaeologist who excavated Jericho in the 1930s and believed he had found the walls that fell for Joshua.
- Kathleen Kenyon
- A British archaeologist who excavated Jericho from 1952 to 1958, digging layer by layer, and redated what Garstang had found.
- Bryant Wood
- An American archaeologist with the Associates for Biblical Research, a christian organisation, who argues the city fell around 1400 BCE.
- Solomon
- A king of Israel, David’s son, who the bible says built the first temple in Jerusalem.
What christians say
Jericho was real, it did have walls that fell, and it was burned. John Garstang, digging in the 1930s, dated that destruction to about 1400 BCE, right where the bible’s own chronology puts Joshua. Kathleen Kenyon later moved it to about 1550 BCE, partly because she found none of a type of imported pottery from Cyprus. In 1990 Bryant Wood re-examined the finds, argued that Garstang had been right, and pointed out that the burned city still had jars full of grain, which fits a short siege just after harvest, as the book describes. The dating is disputed, and the physical remains match the story remarkably well.
If trumpets and a shout flattened the walls of Jericho, why does the rubble date from at least a century too early?