True
god tells the city of Tyre that he’ll scrape it down to bare rock. Fishermen will dry their nets on it, and it will never be built again.
Original wording
And I will make thee like the top of a rock: thou shalt be a place to spread nets upon; thou shalt be built no more: for I the LORD have spoken it, saith the Lord GOD.
Who’s who
- Tyre
- A rich trading port on the coast of what is now southern Lebanon. In Ezekiel’s day its main city stood on an island just offshore. It’s called Tyrus in this chapter.
- Ezekiel
- A Jewish priest and prophet taken to Babylon as a captive around 597 BCE. His book is a collection of visions and messages he says came from god.
- Nebuchadrezzar
- Another spelling of Nebuchadnezzar, king of Babylon, in what is now Iraq, from about 605 to 562 BCE. He destroyed Jerusalem in 587 or 586 BCE.
- Alexander the Great
- A king from Macedon, in what is now northern Greece, who built an empire stretching from Greece to India in the 330s and 320s BCE. He took Tyre in 332 BCE.
What christians say
The chapter says “many nations” will come against Tyre, like waves, so it describes a series of attacks, not one. Nebuchadnezzar destroyed the mainland part of the city. Then, in verse 12, the prophecy switches from “he” to “they,” and centuries later Alexander the Great’s army did exactly what it says: they scraped the ruins of the old mainland city into the sea to build a causeway out to the island, and took it. The site of the old city is bare, and fishermen do spread their nets in the area. The modern town is not the same city that was destroyed.
Where that breaks
Some of it came true, and the answer is right to point that out. Tyre was besieged, and Alexander really did build a causeway out of rubble and take the island in 332 BCE, which is one of the great military stories of the ancient world. But look at who the chapter says will do it. Verses 7 to 11 name Nebuchadrezzar: he’ll break down the towers, ride through the gates, and kill the people in the streets. As far as anyone can tell, he never got through the gates. By the account of Josephus, a first-century Jewish historian, the siege dragged on for thirteen years, and most historians think it ended in a deal, not a sack. We don’t need historians to know it went badly, because Ezekiel says it himself three chapters later. In Ezekiel 29, god admits that Nebuchadrezzar and his army got “no wages” from Tyre for all their work, and promises him Egypt instead as a consolation prize. It’s rare for a prophecy to be revised by the same prophet in the same book, but here we are. As for Alexander, Tyre was rebuilt after he left. In the New Testament jesus visits the region of Tyre and Paul spends a week with christians there. And it’s still there. The chapter ends by saying Tyre will be sought for but “never be found again.” It can be found on a map of Lebanon, and its old town sits on what used to be the island.
If Tyre was never going to be built again, who built the city of Tyre that’s standing there today?