Moral guide
God tells a king to attack a neighbouring tribe and kill everything: men, women, infants, babies still nursing, and the animals.
Original wording
Now go and smite Amalek, and utterly destroy all that they have, and spare them not; but slay both man and woman, infant and suckling, ox and sheep, camel and ass.
Who’s who
- Saul
- The first king of Israel. Chosen by god, later rejected by god for not finishing this job.
- Amalek
- A tribe living south of Israel. Enemies going back generations.
What christians say
The Amalekites were uniquely wicked and had attacked Israel first. God, as the author of life, has the right to end it. And 'kill everything' is ancient war rhetoric, exaggeration that no one took literally.
Where that breaks
If it's rhetoric, Saul didn't get the memo. Later in the same chapter god strips him of the kingdom for leaving the king and the best sheep alive. The story only works if the order was literal. 'God has the right to take life' doesn't help either, because god doesn't do the killing. Soldiers do, with swords, to nursing infants. The defence needs you to believe that a perfectly good being ordered that, that the men who did it were righteous, and that the babies had it coming. Every part of that is what the word 'evil' was invented for.
Kill the babies too, god says. Is that good?